Brent gave up an early jump to trade near $101 in the first session after the G7 agreed to release reserves. Amin Nasser put usable global stocks near 780 million barrels and said refilling reserves would lift demand by 2 million barrels a day for a year and a half.
Macro · FinancialMarkets.com · · Tickers: BNO, USO, XLE, VLO, MPC, UNG
Saudi Aramco's chief executive put a size on the oil market's next squeeze on Monday, and by his own figures it is about twice as large as the shortfall the world is living with now. Energy shares behaved as though some investors were already looking that far ahead.
Brent touched $103.55 shortly after the open, then turned lower and spent the afternoon near $101 a barrel, about 1.2% below Friday's settle. U.S. crude slipped by a similar amount to roughly $90. It was the first full session since Group of Seven governments agreed on Friday to tap their strategic reserves.
Energy equities did not follow. The Energy Select Sector SPDR fund gained about 1.3% in the afternoon, and 19 of its 21 members were higher. Since the U.S.-Iran war began, the fund had risen by more than 1% on a falling-crude day only five times before Monday.
Nasser's arithmetic
Amin Nasser made the case at an industry forum in London. Worldwide crude and product stocks are approaching a "stress level," he said.
Start with the inventory count. By the International Energy Agency's August count, the world held about 7.8 billion barrels, some 500 million short of its prewar total. Nasser argued that almost all of that is locked in pipelines and operating systems, and that about a tenth can actually be drawn. On his figure, that leaves roughly 780 million barrels of usable oil worldwide. The G7's 100 million barrel release equals about 13% of it, which helps explain his remark that governments are "struggling" to free up even that much.
Then the rebuild. Nasser said restoring strategic reserves to prewar levels would add about 2 million barrels a day of demand for 18 months if the conflict ended now. Over a year and a half, that comes to roughly 1.1 billion barrels, about twice the 500 million barrel shortfall in the agency's August count. The difference could reflect further drawdowns he expects before restocking begins, or governments choosing to hold more than they did before the war. Either way, the rebuild he describes would add demand for years after supply routes reopen.
Products told a firmer story
Diesel held up better than crude. Heating oil futures added about 0.8%, to around $4.54 a gallon, and natural gas rose about 0.7%. When refined products stay firm while crude softens, refiners and integrated producers keep more of the margin between them, which is one mechanical reason energy shares could rise on a day like Monday. The other is the longer horizon Nasser described.
Two horizons
The near-term horizon belongs to the release. Barrels from reserves, aimed first at diesel, are meant to arrive over the coming weeks, and Monday's crude decline is consistent with that supply.
The longer horizon belongs to the refill. Equity investors buying energy on a down day for crude are, in effect, valuing cash flows that extend past the release and into a period when governments are buyers rather than sellers. That is one reading, and it fits a sector rising while its main commodity falls.
What would separate them
The spread between heating oil and crude over the next three weeks shows whether the release is easing the product shortage it targets. A narrowing spread with energy shares still firm would suggest equity buyers are looking toward the rebuild. OPEC's monthly report on and any change in traffic through the Strait of Hormuz are the next inputs for crude itself.